Boston Red Sox June 1996 Amateur Draft Picks


Last updated: January 5, 2000


Note: the commentary on this page is provided by Robert Weeks.


Statistics are through the end of the 1999 regular season. Ages given are as of July 1, 2000.

1) Josh Garrett, RHP, South Spencer HS, Richland, IN, age 22

  Year    Team            G     GS     IP     ERA     H     BB     SO   HR
  1996    R/Fort Myers    7      5     27    1.67    22      5     17    0
  1997    A/Michigan     22     22  138.2    4.80   164     35     64   13
  1998    A/Sarasota     26     25  155.1    5.21   182     40     68   17
  1999    A/Sarasota     26     26  149      4.59   189     50     95    9
Garrett has been a somewhat of a disappointment thus far considering he was a first round pick. His second season at Sarasota was a marginal improvement over his first. His "hits per innings pitched ratio" actually grew worse in 1999, although his "strike outs per innings pitched ratio" improved and he allowed fewer home runs. He may be promoted to Trenton in 2000, but maybe partially on the basis of his reputation as a first round pick. Still he is young enough that there remains hope for improvement.
1a) Christopher Reitsma, RHP, Calgary Christian HS, Calgary, age 22

  Year    Team            G     GS     IP     ERA     H     BB     SO   HR
  1996    R/Fort Myers    7      6   32.2    1.35    24      1     32    0
  1997    A/Michigan      9      9   49.2    2.90    57     13     41    4
  1998    A/Sarasota      8      8   12.2    2.84    12      5      9    0
  1999    A/Sarasota     19     19   96.1    5.61   116     31     79   11
Reitsma was considered a top prospect in the Red Sox organization until he injured his pitching elbow in 1997. In 1999, Reitsma finally had a healthy season. Although he pitched somewhat erratically in 1999, he was still considered a prospect by the Red Sox organization. However, because he was not added to the 40 man roster after the 1999 season, he was exposed in the Rule V draft and taken in the second round by Tampa Bay. He must remain with Tampa Bay for the entire 1999 season or else be offered back to the Red Sox. This situation bears monitoring.
2a) Jason Sekany, RHP, University of Virginia, age 24

  Year    Team            G    GS      IP     ERA     H     BB     SO   HR
  1996    R/Fort Myers    5     2    11.2    2.31    14      3     16    1
  1997    A/Michigan     16    16     106    4.08    92     41    103    5
          A/Sarasota     10     9    64.2    5.57    56     41     32    8
  1998    AA/Trenton     28    28   148.2    5.21   151     57    113   21
  1999    AA/Trenton     27    22   161.1    3.35   143     64    116    8
          AAA/Pawtucket   1     1     5.2    4.76     6      4      1    2
In 1999 in his second year at Trenton, Sekany showed significant improvement. He was arguably the ace pitcher of a Trenton team that was one of the top minor league teams last year. His performance should earn him a promotion to Pawtucket in 2000. Hopefully he will have a solid year at Pawtucket in 2000 and will retain his prospect status.
2b) Gary Locurto, 1B/3B, University HS, San Diego CA, age 22

  Year    Team             AB      BA/OBP/SLG     HR    BB    SO    SB/CS
  1996    R/Fort Myers    137     314/401/460      4    18    44      5/4
  1997    A/Michigan      419     236/337/329      4    63    93      8/5
  1998    A/Michigan      188     186/300/229      0    31    52      1/3
  1999    DNP
After a very disappointing 1998 season, Locurto was apparently released by the Red Sox organization.
3) Dernell Stenson 1B/LF, La Grange HS, GA, age 22

  Year    Team             AB      BA/OBP/SLG     HR    BB    SO    SB/CS
  1996    R/Fort Myers     97     216/358/330      2    16    26      4/3
  1997    A/Michigan      471     291/400/469     15    72   105      6/4
  1998    AA/Trenton      505     257/376/446     24    84   135      5/3
  1999    AAA/Pawtucket   440     270/356/466     18    55   119      2/1
          R/Fort Myers     23     217/308/478      2     3     5      0/0
Dernell Stenson is commonly recognized as a top prospect in the Red Sox organization. He was one of the youngest players in the International League in 1999, and after a slow start, more than held his own offensively. In 1999, the Red Sox organization shifted his position (ill-advisedly in this author's opinion) from LF to 1B, perhaps as a reaction to the departure of Mo Vaughn. He struggled defensively in his new position, committing 34 errors in 115 games. Because of his defensive lapses, Baseball America rated Stenson as the Red Sox #2 prospect for 2000 after being rated #1 in 1999.

Over the winter Stenson played both RF and 1B in winter ball in the Dominican Republic. Baseball America reports that the Red Sox are considering moving him back to the outfield, where at least he performed decently prior to 1999. Because of the eventual expected elimination of the DH, it is imperative that the Red Sox find the position for Stenson where he is the most comfortable. At this point it seems to be back in the outfield. a 1B. It is expected that he will start the year 2000 at Pawtucket where the Red Sox hope he will show improvement at 1B. This author hopes he is returned back to LF where at least he performed decently in the field prior to 1999.

4) John Barnes, OF, Grossmont CC, CA, age 24

John Barnes was a decent prospect when he was traded in July 1998 along with pitchers Matt Kinney and Joe Thomas to Minnesota for LHRP Greg Swindell and 1B-DH Orlando Merced. This past year he hit 263/339/400 for the New Britain Rock Cats with 13HR and 10/2SB in his second year at AA. He now appears to be a marginal prospect.
5) Bobby Brito, C, Cypress HS, CA

Brito hit 252/281/339 in 115 AB at Fort Myers in 1996, and then apparently left the game.
6) Michael Perini, CF, Carlsbad HS, NM, age 22

After hitting 220/303/271 in his second season at Fort Myers, Perini apparently left the game.
7) Robert Ramsay, LHP, Washington State, age 26

  Year    Team            G    GS      IP     ERA     H     BB     SO   HR
  1996    R/Fort Myers    2     0     3.2    4.91     5      3      5    0
          A/Sarasota     12     7      34    6.09    42     27     32    1
  1997    A/Sarasota     23    22   135.2    4.78   134     63    115   16
  1998    AA/Trenton     27    27   162.2    3.49   137     50    166   10
  1999    AL/Seattle      6     3    18.1    6.38    23      9     11    3
          AAA/Tacoma      5     5    33.1    1.08    20     14     37    2
          AAA/Pawtucket  20    20   114.1    5.35   114     36     79   21
Ramsay was not able to follow up a strong performance at Trenton in 1998 with an equally strong performance after being promoted to Pawtucket. He was traded in July 1999 to Seattle for RH DH Butch Huskey. After pitching well at Tacoma, he was promoted to Seattle in August. He has an outside chance of making the Seattle club in 2000, but his most likely destination is Tacoma.
8) Justin Duchscherer, RHP, Coronado HS, Lubbock TX, age 22

  Year    Team            G    GS      IP     ERA     H     BB     SO   HR
  1996    R/Fort Myers   13     8    54.2    3.13    52     14     45    0
  1997    R/Fort Myers   10     8    44.2    1.81    34     17     59    0
          A/Michigan      4     4      24    5.63    26     10     19    1
  1998    A/Michigan     30    26   142.2    4.79   166     47    106    9
  1999    A/Augusta       6     6    41.0    0.22    21      8     39    0
          A/Sarasota     20    18   112.1    4.49   101     30    105   14
Duchscherer was absolutely overmatching opponents in 1999 at Augusta when he was promoted to Sarasota. He pitched well at Sarasota (starting at 5-2 2.82) before apparently tiring at Sarasota towards the end of the year. He is a definite prospect who likely will be promoted to Trenton in 2000.
9) Mark Martinez, LHP, Monterey HS, Lubbock, TX, age 22

  Year    Team            G     GS     IP     ERA    H      BB     SO   HR
  1997    R/Fort Myers   14      4   47.2    2.64   35      18     78    1
  1998    DNP
  1999    DNP
After an outstanding season in 1997 at Fort Myers, it is unclear as to what happened to Mark Martinez. Is he injured?
10) Shea Hillenbrand, C, Mesa CC, AZ, age 24

  Year    Team             AB      BA/OBP/SLG     HR    BB    SO    SB/CS
  1996    A/Lowell        279     315/371/416      2    18    32     4/3
  1997    A/Michigan      224     290/315/415      3     9    20     1/3
          A/Sarasota      220     295/320/377      2     7    29     9/8
  1998    A/Michigan      498     349/383/546     19    19    49    13/7
  1999    AA/Trenton      282     259/298/387      7    14    27     6/5
Hillenbrand was promoted from Michigan to Trenton in 1999, bypassing Sarasota and passing over Steve Lomasney in the process. However Hillenbrand was not able to replicate his 1998 success at Michigan at Trenton. His statistics all declined, and he still seems unable to take bases on balls. He had a season ending injury in 1999 and was removed from the 40 man roster. He has since signed a minor league contract and seems destined to start the year 2000 at Trenton. Meanwhile, Steve Lomasney has leapfrogged over Hillenbrand and seems destined to start the year at Pawtucket.
11) Brian Musgrave, LHP, Appalachian State, age 26

  Year    Team            G     GS     IP     ERA     H     BB     SO   HR
  1996    A/Lowell        2      0      5    0.00     4      2      7    0
  1997    A/Michigan     15     11   78.2    5.61    96     17     51   11
  1998    A/Sarasota     28      4     60    6.30    73     31     34    6
  1999    DNP
Musgrove apparently retired in 1999.
12) Dion Ruecker, SS, Texas Tech, age 26

Ruecker apparently retired in 1999. Ruecker had a weak year at Lowell at age 24, and only managed 4 walks in 160 AB. He seems to have retired after that.
13) Skipp Benzing, RHP, Indian Hills CC, Iowa, age 23

In spite of high ERAs Benzing pitched rather well in his first two seasons of professional ball, allowing about a hit per inning with good strikeout totals. Perhaps he didn't agree, however, as he seems to have retired after 1997.
14) Justin Lynch, RHP, Marina HS, Huntington Beach CA, apparently has not signed.

15) Mark Robbins, 3B, Derby HS, KS, apparently has not signed.

16) Jeff Keaveney, 1B, U of Southern Maine, age 24

  Year    Team             AB      BA/OBP/SLG     HR    BB    SO    SB/CS
  1996    A/Lowell        169     249/323/408      4    10    65     1/1
  1997    A/Lowell        191     204/283/377      7    18    58     0/0
  1998    A/Michigan      373     252/372/437     15    65   104     0/2
  1999    A/Augusta        78     205/326/397      4    10    31     0/0
Jeff Keaveny was apparently released by the Red Sox in 1999. He hooked on with the Waterbury Spirit in the Northern League, where he apparently suffered a skull fracture in a freak accident when his bat snapped at the handle.
17) Justin Crisafulli, RHP, Arizona Western JC, apparently has not signed.

18) Michael McKinley, CF, Scottsdale CC, AZ, age 25

Struggled at Lowell in 1996, moved back to Fort Myers in 1997 and seems to have retired thereafter.
19) Michael Rupp, RHP, Monte Vista HS, Spring Valley CA, age 22.

  Year    Team            G     GS     IP     ERA     H     BB     SO   HR
  1997    R/Fort Myers   11      9     59    1.22    51     17     56    0
          A/Lowell        2      2   12.2    3.55     8      3     10    1
  1998    A/Michigan     11     11   48.1    5.03    51     30     48    2
  1999    A/Lowell       18      8   57.1    5.81    72     33     48    2
Michael struggled at Lowell in 1999. His outlook does not look good.
20) Chuck Beale, RHP, Stetson U, age 26

  Year    Team            G     GS     IP     ERA     H     BB     SO   HR
  1996    A/Lowell       28      0     29    1.24    16      7     33    1
  1997    A/Michigan     39      9   89.1    3.73   111     17     86    5
  1998    AA/Trenton     43      0     69    3.26    54     31     39    9
  1999    AA/Trenton     29      1     59    5.95    71     36     41    6
Beale repeated 1999 at Trenton and also seems to have regressed.
21) Javier Fuentes, 3B, Arizona State, age 25

  Year    Team             AB      BA/OBP/SLG     HR    BB    SO    SB/CS
  1996    A/Lowell        157     287/378/376      2    21    23      2/1
  1997    A/Michigan       77     169/273/208      0     7    18      1/1
          A/Sarasota      147     286/344/395      2    12    19      4/6
  1998    A/Sarasota      251     275/385/386      4    38    38      1/2
  1999    A/Augusta       130     254/376/323      1    22    13      6/1
          A/Sarasota      176     290/413/313      0    33    17      6/1
He posted a modest improvement at Sarasota in 1999 over 1998. He does seem to be able to take walks well. However, given his age, his status as a prospect is doubtful.
22) Aaron Harang, RHP, Patrick Henry HS, San Diego CA, apparently has not signed.

23) Paul McCurtain, RHP, Mesa CC, AZ, apparently has not signed.

24) Robert Brandt, RHP, A&M Consolidated HS, College Station TX, apparently has not signed.

25) Dominic Barrett, CF, Trimble Tech HS, Fort Worth TX, apparently has not signed.

26) Chris Thompson, RHP, St. Leo, FL, age 27

  Year    Team            G     GS     IP     ERA     H     BB     SO   HR
  1996    A/Lowell       25      0     47    4.40    43     20     51    2
  1997    A/Michigan      8      0   15.2    1.15    11      1     13    1
          A/Sarasota     29      6     61    3.69    68     35     40    6
  1998    A/Sarasota     30      0   45.1    3.18    48     17     28    1
          AAA/Pawtucket   2      0      3    3.00     3      1      3    1
  1999    AA/Trenton      1      0      1    9.00     2      1      1    0
          A/Sarasota     28      2   43.1    5.61    48     22     41    3
Another player who regressed at the same level in 1999.
27) Ryan Murray, RHP, Tampa Bay Tech HS, FL, apparently has not signed.

28) Erik Metzger, C, Samford Univ, age 24

Hit 195/282/297 at Lowell in 1997, and seems to have retired after that.
29) Joshua Stewart, LHP, Livingston Central HS, Ledbetter KY, apparently has not signed.

30) William Whitaker, LHP, First Coast HS, Jacksonville FL, apparently has not signed.

31) Matthew Frick, C, Yavapai JC, AZ, apparently has not signed.

32) Michael Bynum, LHP, Middleburg HS, FL

Michael Bynum appears to be one who slipped away. He was drafted by the San Diego Padres as the fifth of their six first and supplemental round selections in 1999. He got off to a phenomenal start with a string of 27 consecutive scoreless innings to open his pro career. Basebal America rated Michael as the Padres #4 prospect entering 2000. 33) Adam Roller, RHP, Lakeland HS, FL, age 22.

  Year    Team            G     GS     IP     ERA     H     BB     SO   HR
  1997    R/Fort Myers   10      0     17    3.18     7     14     21   0
  1998    R/Fort Myers   15      2     39    4.85    51     22     27   3
  1999    A/Lowell       23      0     39    2.54    30     29     41   1
          A/Sarasota      1      0    2.2   16.88     5      2      2   1
A modest improvement in 1999, although control is a concern. He was old for his league and needs to begin to show improvement at higher levels in order to be considered a prospect.
34) Jaime Bonilla, LHP, Lake City CC, FL, apparently has not signed.

35) Kasey Kuhlmeyer, LHP, San Pasqual HS, Escondido CA, apparently has not signed.

36) Kenneth Sarna, SS, Durango HS, Las Vegas NV, apparently has not signed.

37) Jeremy Swindell, LHP, Clear Lake HS, Houston TX, apparently has not signed.

38) Travis McRoberts, SS, El Capitan HS, El Cajon CA, apparently has not signed.

39) Jessie (Andre) Thompson, RF, Delta State.

Appears to have retired after a 168/226/280 season at Lowell in '96.
40) Curtis Anthony, SS, Bishop Gorman HS, Las Vegas NV, apparently has not signed.

41) No selection in this round.

42) Wesley Warren, OF, Arcadia HS, Scottsdale AZ, apparently has not signed.

43) Jamaon Halbig, C, Southwestern JC, CA, apparently has not signed.

44) Barton Vaughn, RHP, Manatee JC, FL, apparently has not signed.


Class of 1996, status after 1998:
        AAA/Pawtucket            3 
        AA/Trenton               3
        A/Sarasota               5
        A/Augusta                1
        A-/Lowell                1
        Traded                   2
        Unclear                  1

        Out of baseball          7
        Unsigned                22  
Percentage of 45 draftees signed: 51%
Percentage of 23 signed players retained: 69%

Players Still with the Organization:

Pitchers: 8 (67%)
Hitters: 4 (33%)
Thoughts about the 1996 draft
The 1996 draft has produced our top prospect at this time, Dernell Stenson. Stenson should see some time in the major leagues in 2000, and should be promoted for good in 2001. Robert Ramsay was the first prospect in this draft to make the major leagues; how long he will stay in the major leagues remains questionable.

Jason Sekany and Justin Dushscherer had solid seasons in 1999. Hopefully both will build on their successes at the next level in 2000. Josh Garrett and Shea Hillenbrand are both possibilities. Chris Reitsma remains a prospect who hopefully will return to the Red Sox after being taken by Tampa Bay in the Rule V draft.

This draft may be an acceptible draft if Stenson develops into a star, or if one other player from this draft develops into a solid major league player. It is disappointing that the two number one picks in this draft have not progressed as much as we might have hoped.

Please forward any corrections or observations to my email address below. I will attempt to update this page in a timely manner.



Back to Red Sox Draft Page


Robert Weeks/ rweeks@sover.net /Last modified January 5, 2000